When to Call a Handyman vs. a Specialist Contractor
Choosing between a handyman and a specialized contractor can be confusing. Here’s a straightforward guide to help you make the right call for your project.
Q: What’s the difference between a handyman and a specialist contractor?
A: A handyman is a skilled generalist who handles a wide variety of smaller repairs, installations, and improvements across multiple trades. Think of us as your home’s general practitioner—we can diagnose and fix most common issues.
Specialist contractors (electricians, plumbers, HVAC technicians, etc.) are licensed experts who focus on one specific trade. They handle complex, large-scale, or code-intensive work that requires specialized training and licensing.
Q: When should I call a handyman?
A: Choose a handyman for:
- Small to medium repairs: Leaky faucets, squeaky doors, minor drywall damage
- Multi-trade projects: Jobs that need a little bit of everything (painting, minor electrical, carpentry)
- Installations: Shelving, TV mounting, light fixtures, ceiling fans
- General maintenance: Caulking, weatherstripping, minor deck repairs
- Odd jobs: Those items on your to-do list that don’t fit a specialty category
- Cost-effective solutions: Handyman rates are typically lower than specialized contractors
Q: When do I need a specialist contractor?
A: Call a specialist for:
- Major electrical work: Panel upgrades, rewiring, adding circuits (requires licensed electrician)
- Complex plumbing: Moving pipes, sewer line work, water heater installation (requires licensed plumber)
- HVAC systems: Furnace or AC installation, ductwork, refrigerant handling
- Structural changes: Removing walls, foundation work, major framing
- Roofing: Full roof replacement, major leak repairs
- Projects requiring permits: Most municipalities require licensed contractors for permitted work
The Gray Area
Some projects fall in between. For example:
- Installing a new faucet: Handyman territory
- Replacing a main water line: Specialist required
- Replacing a light fixture: Handyman can handle it
- Adding new electrical circuits: Need a licensed electrician
- Patching drywall: Perfect for a handyman
- Major drywall installation: Consider a drywall specialist
How to Decide
Ask yourself these questions:
- Does it require a permit? If yes, you likely need a specialist.
- Is it a major system? (electrical panel, HVAC, structural) Go with a specialist.
- Is it within code limits? Minor electrical/plumbing that doesn’t require permits is usually handyman-friendly.
- What’s your comfort level? If you’re unsure, ask! A good handyman will tell you when a specialist is the better choice.
Our Philosophy
At House Doctor, we’re honest about our capabilities. If your project requires a licensed specialist, we’ll tell you upfront and can often recommend trusted professionals. We’d rather refer you to the right person than take on work we’re not qualified to do.
When you call us, we’ll assess your needs and give you an honest answer about whether we’re the right fit—or if you need a specialist for the job.
Need help deciding? Contact us to discuss your project. We’re happy to provide guidance even if we’re not the right fit for the work.